วันพุธที่ 12 มิถุนายน พ.ศ. 2556

World Economic Analysis



IMF cut 2013 global economic outlook


          The International Monetary Fund (IMF) revised down the world growth forecast of this year 0.2% from 3.5% to 3.3% while remained the 2014 forecast at 4%. This information is also supported by the recent the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)’s global economic forecast that OECD cut this year forecast from 3.4% to 3.1% and the next year forecast from 4.2% to 4%. The initial forecast of OECD was constructed in November last year. The recent adjustment of the forecasts from IMF and OECD show the negative sign of global economy. Furthermore, the major concerns are eurozone’s ability to get through its crisis and the ability of the US and Japan to cut public sector deficits and debt.

US economy is still not good

The US economy is gradually getting better due to lower unemployment rate from 8.1% in May 2012 to 7.5% in May 2013. The consumer confidence is at a five-year high and new claims for jobless benefits at a five-year low. There are other indicators that show a good sign of US economy: increasing in sales of car and light-truck, higher home sales and rising in the stock prices. However, government spending cut and hike in tax rate is really harming the US economy growth, as a result, IMF estimates the economic growth to be 1.9%.

Euro zone is facing recession

          The IMF forecasts the economy of France, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Greece, Netherlands, Cyprus, and Slovenia to be contracted in this year thanks to the tight lending conditions for companies and households, job cuts and frozen investment. This is the result of sovereign debt crisis and banking troubles. The financial crisis has left 19.2 million workers with no job and is required a trillions of euros injecting into financial sector. The unemployment rate is 12.2% in 2013 up from 11.4% last year. Therefore, the eurozone growth forecast is projected to contract 0.3% but expected to be grow at 1.1% in 2014.

Asia economic growth is outperforming the world



          Asia may not be booming, but it is growing sustainably. Hence IMF expects Asia to grow at 5.7% in 2013 (with growth in emerging Asia reaching 7.2%), contributed from strong growth in China and some ASEAN economies. Consumption and private investment will be encouraged by continued robust domestic demand, favorable conditions in labor market, and low unemployment rate in several countries. Furthermore, Chinese demand and Japanese stimulus provide a boost to the region. We present the outlook of some leading countries in Asia which are China, Japan, India, and South Korea.

China: According to in data from The National Bureau of Statistics of the People’s Republic of China or NBS, China’s economy grew 7.8% in 2012 which is the slowest rate in 13 years, and authorities set their growth at a conservative 7.5%. This is the result of lower exports from declined demand in US and European markets.
Japan: Japan’s economy is gradually recovering. According to the statement of Bank of Japan and Japanese government, they upgrade its outlook of the economy as there is an upturn in exports and factory output. However the economic condition is still questionable because the exports rose just 3.8% in April which is below expectations of 5% gain from a Dow Jones Newswires survey and 5.9% increase from Reuters.
India: IMF lowered its forecast on India’s economic growth to 5.7% this year from its January forecast of 5.9% and also revised its 2014 growth forecast 6.2% from 6.3%. Downgraded economic outlook is caused by decreased investments and demand. India’s economic troubles are shown in high inflation and negative atmosphere among businesses and consumers.
South Korea: The South Korea’s finance ministry lowered its 2013 growth target to 2.3% from its estimate of 3% on March because of declined exports and sluggish domestic consumption.

Domestic consumption plays a vital role in boosting Southeast Asia economic growth


Rising private investment, increased intra-regional trade and higher domestic consumption are the main drivers to continue Southeast Asia’s growth momentum, while Europe is facing recession and US is not showing the clear sign of recovery. As a result, Asian Development Bank (ADB) forecasts GDP growth in developing Asia of 6.6% in 2013 and 6.7% in 2014 while the region’s growth was 6.1% in 2012. As presented below, Standard Cartered has a positive view on the Southeast Asia Economy.

Indonesia: In spite of faster inflation, strong household consumption and investment drive the real GDP growth from 6.2% in 2012 to 6.5% this year and 6.8% in 2014.
Malaysia: Malaysia economy is mainly driven by domestic spending and likely to enjoy sustained investment growth in 2013. Standard Cartered forecasts GDP economic growth to slow to 4.7% this year from 5.6% in 2012.
Singapore: The Singapore economic growth is estimated to be 1.3% in 2012, following a weak 1.3% in 2012. Singapore’s growth outlook is viewed to be subdued.
Vietnam: Vietnam has approved a master plan to boost the economy which is concentrated on restructuring the banking sector and state-owned enterprise during the 2013 -2020 period. Vietnam economy is expected to show mild recovery in 2013 with its GDP growth of 5.5% this year from 5% in 2012.

วันศุกร์ที่ 15 กุมภาพันธ์ พ.ศ. 2556

Unbelievable! Coca Cola is 65% undervalued




Valuation (KO):

Method: Dividend Discount Model because the growth of dividend per share is relatively stable.

Holding Period: Coca Cola is the defensive stock because of its low beta (0.721) and doing business in the consumer product. Furthermore, Coca Cola is the large market-capitalization stock and have a lot of liquidity and stable leverage. Investors can hold this stock for a long term (10 years or more) with low market risk, therefore we use 10 years which is the long-term investment horizon for the holding period of Coca Cola and expect to sell this stock in 2021.

Growth: We use the 10-year compound annual growth rate of DPS (13.74%) and EPS (11.87%) to be the growth rate of DPS and EPS respectively because the growth rate of DPS and EPS is relatively stable.


Growth of Dividend:
CAGR of DPS (10-year average)
8.92%
Growth of EPS:
CAGR of EPS (10-year average)
11.87%

Terminal Value: We plan the sell Coca Cola stock in the next 10 years, so we use the average of past 10-year P/E and forecast the EPS to multiply with P/E to stock price in the next 10 years. We are confident that the P/E is suitable due to stability of KO’s P/E and being the defensive stock with stable growth of EPS.


Average of 10-year PE
19.59
EPS Growth Rate
11.87%
EPS
2011
1.89
2012
2.12
2013
2.37
2014
2.65
2015
2.97
2016
3.32
2017
3.71
2018
4.15
2019
4.64
2020
5.20
2021
5.81
Terminal Value
113.87
We forecast the EPS at the end of 2021 to be 5.81 and multiply with the 10-year average of PE to get the price of Coca Cola of $113.87 in the next 10 years. We expect to sell Coca Cola at the end of 2021 to get the cash of $113.87.

Cash Flow Received from Dividend and Stock:

DPS Growth Rate
8.92%
DPS in 2011
0.94
(1)
(2)
(1) + (2)
DPS
Terminal Value
Cash Flow
2012
1.02
1.02
2013
1.12
1.12
2014
1.21
1.21
2015
1.32
1.32
2016
1.44
1.44
2017
1.57
1.57
2018
1.71
1.71
2019
1.86
1.86
2020
2.03
2.03
2021
2.21
113.87
116.08

WACC: We use the market return (Rm) from Bloomberg and risk free rate from10-year government bond rate (Rf) as inputs in CAPM(Capital Asset Pricing Model) to get the market risk premium (Rm - Rf) of 8.72%. Therefore we get the cost of equity (Ke) equal to 8.13%.

Cost of Equity (CAPM)
Rm
10.56%
Rf
1.84%
Rm - Rf
8.72%
Beta
0.721
Ke
8.13%
            
 Fair Value:

Ke
8.13%
Cash Flow
Discounted Cash Flow
1
2012
1.02
0.95
2
2013
1.12
0.95
3
2014
1.21
0.96
4
2015
1.32
0.97
5
2016
1.44
0.97
6
2017
1.57
0.98
7
2018
1.71
0.99
8
2019
1.86
1.00
9
2020
2.03
1.00
10
2021
116.08
53.12
Intrinsic Value
61.90

Intrinsic Value
61.90
Market Value
37.54
Undervalues
64.89%

We discount the cash flow with cost of equity of 8.13% to get the intrinsic value of $64.89 which is 64.89% higher than the market value. Therefore we recommend you to buy Coca Cola stock.


There are some reasons that I am confident that my valuation is correct. Firstly, Asia or other developing countries have a high potential to grow. As shown in the table above, Indian and Chinese people drink Coke just only 11 and 34 bottles per year respectively whereas US people drink it 394 bottles per year. Secondly, KO has a great marketing and distribution channel that can create strong brand value for Coke. Coke also use high leverage and repurchase its stocks back every year which magnify the EPS and DPS for Coke. But you should aware of the failure of the Coke products and people concern more on their health which can slow down the growth rate of KO.

Reference: All information is obtained from Bloomberg.



      Appendix:

Historical 10 years P/E, EPS & DPS (Quarterly)
Date
Trailing 12-month P/E
Trailing 12-month EPS
Trailing 12-month DPS
31/12/2002
25.4884
0.86
0.4
31/3/2003
23.5349
0.86
0.41
30/6/2003
26.52
0.875
0.42
30/9/2003
24.2712
0.885
0.43
31/12/2003
27.4324
0.925
0.44
31/3/2004
25.533
0.985
0.455
30/6/2004
24.5049
1.03
0.47
30/9/2004
19.4417
1.03
0.485
31/12/2004
20.2136
1.03
0.5
31/3/2005
20.1304
1.035
0.515
30/6/2005
19.7867
1.055
0.53
30/9/2005
19.8119
1.09
0.545
30/12/2005
18.4908
1.09
0.56
31/3/2006
19.0318
1.1
0.575
30/6/2006
19.0354
1.13
0.59
29/9/2006
19.342
1.155
0.605
29/12/2006
20.3586
1.185
0.62
30/3/2007
19.6721
1.22
0.635
29/6/2007
20.5137
1.275
0.65
28/9/2007
21.7689
1.32
0.665
31/12/2007
22.7296
1.35
0.68
31/3/2008
21.6619
1.405
0.7
30/6/2008
17.5017
1.485
0.72
30/9/2008
17.1133
1.545
0.74
31/12/2008
14.3714
1.575
0.76
31/3/2009
14.0415
1.565
0.775
30/6/2009
15.7862
1.52
0.79
30/9/2009
17.7228
1.515
0.805
31/12/2009
18.6885
1.525
0.82
31/3/2010
17.2414
1.595
0.835
30/6/2010
15.006
1.67
0.85
30/9/2010
17.0116
1.72
0.865
31/12/2010
18.8453
1.745
0.88
31/3/2011
18.7401
1.77
0.895
30/6/2011
18.4863
1.82
0.91
30/9/2011
18.0642
1.87
0.925
30/12/2011
18.3168
1.91
0.94
30/3/2012
19.124
1.935
0.96
29/6/2012
19.9974
1.955
0.98
28/9/2012
19.5013
1.945
1